Holiday Porch Pirates

Published: Oct 03, 2023


Holiday porch pirates header

Ho-Ho-Hold on to Your Packages: The Porch Pirate Epidemic During the Holidays

Key Takeaways

  • During the holidays, 36% of U.S. and 32% of U.K. residents fall victim to porch piracy.
  • The most common days of the week for porch pirates to strike are Wednesdays and Thursdays.
  • Over 60% of U.S. and U.K. residents believe porch piracy has increased in their neighborhoods over the past year.
  • 20% of delivery drivers have personally witnessed a porch pirate in action.

The festive cheer of the holiday season brings with it the joy of online shopping and giving beautifully wrapped gifts. But lurking in the shadows of this celebratory time is an uninvited Grinch: the porch pirate. As e-commerce booms and doorsteps become inundated with parcels, avoiding package theft is a challenge confronting both consumers and delivery drivers. Drawing insights from both sides of the door—the eager recipient and the diligent delivery person—we aim to uncover the actions of these modern-day menaces and help you avoid porch piracy this season.

The Consumer Perspective

The rapid rise of e-commerce, especially during the festive season, has ushered in an era of convenience and challenges. As doorsteps become a prime target for opportunistic thieves, we explored the patterns of these porch pirates in both the U.S. and the U.K. Here’s what we found.

Consumer encounters with holiday porch pirates.

In the U.S., porch pirate incidents peaked during holidays like Christmas, Black Friday, and Prime Day. Similarly, U.K. residents experienced a surge in such incidents during the same holidays but to a lesser degree. Thefts occurred for 36% of U.S. and 32% of U.K. residents. Sadly, nearly 70% of the packages intercepted by these pirates were meant to be heartfelt gifts, casting a shadow over festivities in both nations.

As we looked deeper into the data, we noticed that Wednesdays and Thursdays were the most favored days for these miscreants. Wednesday was slightly more common in the U.K., while packages were stolen more frequently on Thursdays in the States. Timing-wise, the afternoon proved to be the prime window for these illicit activities on both sides of the Atlantic.

As we gear up for another season of gifting and receiving, understanding these trends becomes paramount in safeguarding our cherished parcels.

Defending the Doorstep 

Next, let’s learn how U.S. and U.K. residents cope with package theft and attempt to prevent it.

Porch piracy awareness and prevention.

Interestingly, when it comes to seeking redress, U.K. residents have the upper hand. They were 15% more likely than their U.S. counterparts to secure refunds for pilfered packages.

To thwart these opportunistic thieves, 53% of Americans installed security or doorbell cameras, while 51% scheduled deliveries for when they were home. Over 1 in 4 took the extra step of leaving specific delivery instructions. Meanwhile, across the pond, 61% of U.K. residents preferred to schedule deliveries for when they would be present, 49% provided delivery instructions, and just 25% relied on cameras.

Despite their different preventive measures, a common glaring issue surfaced—delivery drivers disregarded 57% of delivery instructions in the U.S., and a staggering 76% did so in the U.K. Consequently, roughly 10% had their packages stolen. The sentiment on the streets was also unanimous: Over 60% of residents from both nations believed that porch piracy rates had surged in their areas in the past year.

Yet, in a display of community spirit and vigilance, seven in 10 individuals, irrespective of their nationality, confirmed they’d step in if they witnessed a stranger attempting to make away with a package from a neighbor’s front step.

From the Front Porch to the Frontline

Navigating the traffic, streets, and weather, delivery drivers are the unsung heroes ensuring our packages arrive safely at our doorsteps. However, these diligent workers often find themselves on the frontline, witnessing the rising menace of porch piracy. What challenges do they face, and how do their experiences shed light on this growing issue?

Delivery driver sentiments of porch pirates.

A concerning 20% of delivery drivers reported witnessing a porch pirate in the act, snatching away packages moments after they’d been placed on a doorstep. Even more unsettling, over 15% stated they’ve felt the unnerving sensation of being trailed, with potential pirates lurking behind, waiting for an opportune moment. These opportunistic thieves seem to be most active between the peak hours of 12 p.m. and 5 p.m., targeting packages during the busiest delivery window.

To combat this issue, drivers have some sage advice for consumers. They recommend the installation of security cameras to oversee porch areas, which not only act as a deterrent but also provide evidence if theft occurs. Opting for delivery times when residents are sure to be home can minimize the window of opportunity for theft. Further, innovations such as smart doorbells or security systems can send real-time alerts upon package delivery, ensuring recipients are promptly informed.

From the industry’s perspective, several innovative practices are emerging to tackle this problem head-on. Introducing “delivery windows” allows customers to select the most convenient drop-off times, ensuring they’re present to collect their packages. The concept of secure lockers in residential zones is also gaining traction. These lockers act as safe drop-off points, ensuring packages remain protected until collected by the rightful owner.

Safeguarding Our Gifts in the E-Commerce Era

As we explored the world of doorstep dilemmas and parcel pilferers, one thing became clear: Both U.S. and U.K. residents grapple with this issue, though in their own ways. While many people employ preventive measures, our findings underscore the urgency for more robust solutions and constant vigilance. Residents, delivery drivers, and neighbors can all work together to ensure a safer community for all, no matter the season.



We surveyed 500 U.S. and 500 U.K. residents to gauge their perception of porch piracy during the holiday season. The average age of respondents was 39 in the U.S. and 45 in the U.K. Among the U.S. respondents, 41% were male, 57% were female, and 2% were non-binary. Of U.K. respondents, 34% were male, 65% were female, and 1% were non-binary. The U.S. generational breakdown comprised 12% baby boomers, 22% Gen X, 52% millennials, and 13% Gen Z. As for the U.K., 12% were baby boomers, 28% were Gen X, 50% were millennials, and 10% were Gen Z.

About Lance Surety Bonds

Lance Surety Bonds is a premier provider of surety bonds, offering a comprehensive range of bonding solutions. With our unwavering commitment to exceptional service and our deep expertise in the bonding industry, we assist our clients in securing the bonds they require quickly and efficiently.

Fair Use Statement

We encourage sharing this information to raise awareness about porch piracy during the holiday season and promote safety and security for online shoppers and delivery drivers. Please do so for noncommercial purposes only and provide proper attribution with a link to this original article.

Get a FREE Surety Bond Quote in Minutes

  • cta-banner--shild
    Fast and Secure Application
  • cta-banner--money-back
    Money Back Guarantee
  • cta-banner--clock
    Approval in Minutes
  • cta-banner--coverage
    Nationwide Coverage
Get a FREE Surety Bond Quote in Minutes
  • Fast and Secure Application
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Approval in Minutes
  • Money Back Guarantee
Companies we work with:
  • Image
  • Image
    Philadelphia insurance companies
  • Image
About Lance Surety Bonds

Lance Surety Bond Associates, Inc. is a surety bond agency based out of southeastern Pennsylvania that is able to write all surety bond types in all 50 states. We are dedicated to servicing all of our customers' surety bonding needs throughout the country and guarantee competitive rates, timely responses, and unparalleled customer service.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Stay updated with the latest by subscribing to our newsletter below.
Thanks for subscribing!